Criticism of Quranists


Yahoo Answers keep getting deleted so I will copy and paste here.
http://au.answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qid=20110606080850AAH2v33

How Clear Is The Hypocrisy Of “Quranists” Who Claim To Believe In Some Of The Sunnah ?

Assalam Alaikum dear brothers/sisters. Due to their fitnah on Answers:►The only Sunnah they accept is what will fit their desires (but even clear kuffar, not hypocrites like them who are hidden kuffar, accept some of the Qur’an and Sunnah – i.e, that which suits Their desires. Exactly the SAME attitude as them)►Further proof of their Hypocrisy is, they are Not consistent with which hadith to choose and which to reject – the Only consistent methodology they have is: Accept and Reject Based On Desires. (Whichever Hadith They Feel Is Consistent With Qur’an, they Accept. Otherwise, they Reject. In other words, their Whims & Desires is their Hadith Authentication Methodology)

►Their Fitnah is greater than those Quranists who openly and clearly reject all ahadith, because they are more clearly in error. So this is an advice to the brothers/sisters to protect their Iman from the doubts they try to cause. If our goal is Paradise & the Pleasure of Allah swt, then we have to be upon the way of the Sahabah (ra). Your views?

Answers (3)

Show:                  All Answers                 Oldest to Newest                 Newest to Oldest                 Rated Highest to Lowest
  • Without Sunnah of Prophet(as) Islaam would be the Same as Christianity and Judaism!Following, believing Hadith(Sunnah) is not problem at all for a Muslim !Salaam !

    • 2 people rated this as good
  • Simply said: Any Muslim who disregards part of the Sunnah, Fiqh, or Shariah is an open act of disbelief.The Prophet PBUH said ” Anything taken from, or added to this religion in an innovation” His prophecy’s remain true as unfortunately some of the ummah has divided itself into sect’s.Astaghfir’Ullah

    • 1 person rated this as good
  • Th critical things to follow are what decreed by God in the Quran.
    • 6 minutes ago
    Related posts:
Advertisements

One Response to Criticism of Quranists

  1. //Further proof of their Hypocrisy is, they are Not consistent with which hadith to choose and which to reject – the Only consistent methodology they have is: Accept and Reject Based On Desires. (Whichever Hadith They Feel Is Consistent With Qur’an, they Accept. Otherwise, they Reject. In other words, their Whims & Desires is their Hadith Authentication Methodology)//

    Sounds like… what “normal” Muslims would do. They every-day people.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: